Pie Menu

Each day, we bake from scratch at Peggy Jean’s Pies.  We offer 15-18 different varieties of pie every day and are open to walk-in customers.  We do offer gluten-free pies in a limited number of flavors.  Please note the menu below for the (*available as Gluten Free specification).

At this time, we do not offer seating for dine-in customers.

To ensure availability, please call one day in advance to reserve your pie choices.  Holiday pie orders must be pre-placed.  We do offer prepared, ready-to-bake pies for purchase (complete with baking instructions!) in our storefront freezer on a daily basis.

Our prices vary based on the pie flavor, but as a general rule, fruit and cream pies are on the lower end of the price range and pies containing nuts are on the higher end of the price range:

Tart (three inch pie): $2.50 each if boxed or $3.00 each if the tart is bagged and ribboned.

Jelly Jar pie (four ounce pie baked in a Mason jar):  $3 each or six for $25.00.  Available for nationwide shipping.  Shipping cost depends on final destination.  Please call our storefront for additional information or visit the “Ship Pies” tab above.

Baby pie (five inches, approximately 1.5 to 2 slices):  $7-$8

Nine inch pie (approximately six to eight slices depending on how generously the pie is sliced):  $17-$20.50

12 inch pie (approximately ten to 12 slices depending on how generously the pie is sliced):  $23.50-$25.50

Volume discounts are available, please contact Peggy Jean’s Pies or pies@pjpies.com for more information.

At this time, delivery is available for orders over $100 within the limits of City of Columbia.

Image of pie

Fruit

  • American Apple
  • Blackberry
  • Blueberry
  • Blueberry Streusel
  • Boozy Blueberry
  • Caramel Apple (brown sugar/butter crumble topping with homemade caramel sauce)
  • Cherry
  • Drunken Apple
  • Dutch Apple (brown sugar/butter crumble topping)
  • Gooseberry
  • Mixed Berry (blueberry, blackberry, raspberry)
  • Old-Fashioned Peach
  • Old-Fashioned Raisin
  • Peach Praline (brown sugar/butter/pecan crumble topping)
  • Rhubarb
  • Sour Cream Cherry
  • Sour Cream Raisin
  • Sweet Potato
  • Strawberry Rhubarb
Image of pie

Cream

  • Almond Rum Raspberry
  • Banana Cream*
  • Brown Butter Chess
  • Chocolate Cream*
  • Chocolate Banana*
  • Chocolate Mint*
  • Coconut Cream*
  • Coconut Custard
  • Egg Custard
  • French Silk (*available Gluten-Free)
  • Key Lime (*available Gluten-Free)
  • Lemon Cream* (*available Gluten-Free)
  • Peanut Butter (*available Gluten-Free)
  • Pumpkin
  • Pumpkin Chiffon
  • Raisin Cream*
  • White Chocolate Strawberry (*available Gluten-Free)

**Our cream pies are available with a homemade whipped topping in our storefront location.  We are happy to meringue your cream pie at no additional cost, but we do require advance notification.

 

Nut

  • Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
  • Southern Pecan Pie (*available Gluten-Free)
  • German Chocolate (*available Gluten-Free)
Image of pie

Savory

We create our pot pies completely from scratch and then pop them in our freezer unbaked so that you can swing by and take one home to bake fresh in your oven!  Completely delicious, our pot pies are subject to availability.  Please call our storefront to ensure availability.  We prepare our pot pies in both the five inch personal sizes and nine inch family size.

  • Pot Pie – Beef
  • Pot Pie – Chicken