Breaking News!

Our steady march toward #WorldPieDomination took an ENORMOUS leap forward last week when our White Chocolate Strawberry pie was named one of the BEST PIES IN AMERICA by Food Network.  Honestly, we just couldn’t be more honored.

If you haven’t stopped by to try it, our White Chocolate Strawberry pie deserves all the accolades in the world.  Created by Jeanne herself, this pie starts with a crust baked to perfection.  We layer a delicious mixture of white chocolate, cream cheese, and heavy whipping cream to make a dreamy base for a pile of fresh strawberries.  To finish it off, we take the juice of those berries, sugar, and heavy whipping cream and make the most beautiful light pink homemade whipping cream ever created.  This pie feels like spring and tastes even better.


Pie is Home

We make high-end gourmet pies with only fresh ingredients that are never canned or frozen.

See our Pies

We Ship Pies!

In town and around the USA. Get Jelly Jars delivered to your door nationwide!

Order Now

Parties & Events

Celebrate your next event with PJP!  Whether you are looking for a unique place to fete a birthday, host a shower, or just hang out with friends…Peggy Jean’s Pies is the place to be.

Book Your Party

#WorldPieDomination Blog

World Pie Domination

Time Well Spent

Well, if you are keeping track, today we sold NO Reddi-whip at all...which maybe just means that zero out of four people are interested in purchasing aerosol whipping cream.  Or today wasn't a representative sample of whipping cream sales to come and my general nature...

read more


Not to break the Internet with this announcement or anything, but Behind-The-Scenes Jason has conceded that the vintage refrigerator from the shop DOES INDEED look pretty cute on our screened in porch at home.  And I'm completely using this platform to declare all of...

read more

End of an Era…

Today we wrapped an era at PJP known affectionately as the "those years we used a retro refrigerator in our store" era.  If you recall, one of our first purchases after opening PJP was a 1954 refrigerator from a Craigslist ad.  I'm fairly certain we paid $400 for the...

read more